review33.com:影音天地:LS3/5A 同好會

分類搜尋 移民 | 借錢 | 投資 | 物流 | 搬運 | 按揭 | 樓盤 | 保險 | 機票 | 酒店 | 升學 | 補習 | 手錶 | 電腦 | 紅酒 | 網購 | 脫髮 | 健身 | 減肥 | 濕疹

影音天地主旨 ﹝請按主旨作出回應﹞ 上頁下頁首頁尾頁

寄件者

傳送日期

[#17118] LS3/5A 同好會新機都係得Rogers 70週年係made in England ?		1186 正式會員 14.xxx.xxx.12	2018-04-11 16:32

[#17119] LS3/5A 同好會
齋說丹圓刀不是那回事啦！

cat2013

正式會員
219.xxx.xxx.54

2018-04-11 22:54

[#17120] LS3/5A 同好會
當年今日 , my LS3/5A , made in UK ,2013

joellee888

正式會員
119.xxx.xxx.99

2018-06-06 16:29

[#17121] LS3/5A 同好會
正！

Summilux

正式會員
1.xxx.xxx.164

2018-06-06 16:34

[#17122] LS3/5A 同好會
35A

WUXW

會員
114.xxx.xxx.238

2018-06-06 20:49

[#17123] LS3/5A 同好會
玩35x最重要金F腳才有豐滿收穫的,"否則" 。。。啦

我看到了,是最佳的貨色

cat2013

正式會員
58.xxx.xxx.231

2018-06-07 11:47

[#17124] LS3/5A 同好會
借位一用,

今早有網友無心之失發表了 :“音響展認住呢班麻煩友”討論一事, 俾官方關掉了,10分正確值得一贊。

所以任何“討論”沒有問題的, 主要: 不涉及人身“攻擊”及個人“私隱”就是了。

cat2013

正式會員
116.xxx.xxx.51

2018-06-07 18:43

[#17125] LS3/5A 同好會
最近好有興趣收3/5a回來玩，遇上一對，但感覺不太對路，怕有假，或有問題，發上來比大家睇下，有無問題，歡迎發表意見。

064009

會員
210.xxx.xxx.172

2018-06-09 23:00

[#17126] LS3/5A 同好會
同上面一對

064009

會員
210.xxx.xxx.172

2018-06-09 23:01

[#17127] LS3/5A 同好會
同上面一對

064009

會員
210.xxx.xxx.172

2018-06-09 23:02

[#17128] LS3/5A 同好會
同上面一對，高音

064009

會員
210.xxx.xxx.172

2018-06-09 23:03

[#17129] LS3/5A 同好會
又想人哋捽錢落個袋，又唔畀的心機摷35a的料，嘥氣!

fish616

會員
203.xxx.xxx.245

2018-06-10 11:33

[#17130] LS3/5A 同好會
"但感覺不太對路，怕有假，或有問題"

請問是什麼意思?
有什麼不對路? 太便宜? 太殘舊?
還是聲音不像35a?

spyder

正式會員
14.xxx.xxx.23

2018-06-10 19:47

[#17131] LS3/5A 同好會
兩方面：
一系怕假貨，后面的標簽貼得如此不正；
二系怕高音有維修過，好似有維修的痕跡。
多謝高手指導。

064009

會員
183.xxx.xxx.195

2018-06-10 20:18

[#17132] LS3/5A 同好會
1. 不像假貨
2. Label 係差少少，但即使沒有label 也對声音沒影響的。

玩3/5a 最重要是音色，你覺得她好声便是 "真"，否則真假對你來說也沒意思。
11歐很少假貨，你的是11歐，高低音單元也是 Harbeth 早期生產式樣。金色十字鑼絲也是 Harbeth 獨有。
黑色木箱是較廉價版本，Harbeth 出過少量黑檀木版本。

spyder

正式會員
14.xxx.xxx.23

2018-06-10 21:29

[#17133] LS3/5A 同好會
多謝師兄的回復，明解。

064009

會員
183.xxx.xxx.195

2018-06-10 22:56

[#17134] LS3/5A 同好會
1000蚊有嫁,10蚊亦有假嗎？

cat2013

正式會員
219.xxx.xxx.80

2018-06-11 09:49

[#17135] LS3/5A 同好會
#17133
講多少少，harbeth 的11ohm 35a 在一個叫ls35a.com的網站上有記錄在2000年，曾做過很認真的測試，harb 11ohm 是得分最高的35a，這個測試結果很有參考價值。但香港用家較愛15ohm 的。
該結可能是那個盲聽測試的參與者為歐洲人，用的器材是黑胶加石機，而不是主編提倡的胆機。
港人也較愛胆機，可能是因無間道電影。

spyder

正式會員
14.xxx.xxx.23

2018-06-11 10:23

[#17136] LS3/5A 同好會
Harbeth第一代3/5a印象中係一個叫Martin Collins嘅英國寫手評為得分最高嘅3/5a

Grosso1688

會員
119.xxx.xxx.42

2018-06-11 11:26

[#17137] LS3/5A 同好會
In order to avoid copyright, just copy part of the information from ls35a.com

** The Hi Fi News LS3/5A Shootout **

This article was published in the June 2001 issue of HiFi News and is the copyright of Ken Kessler and IPC Media. It may not be reproduced elsewhere without permission. It appears here by kind permission of Ken Kessler and HiFi News.

It's all because of an e-mail. Paul Whatton, who turned out to be quite 'local', had organised a news group on-line, devoted to BBC LS3/5As. Normally, I avoid such groups - I'll give a bottle of Scotch to the individual who can get me off the frikkin' Joenet - but this was different: Paul is the son of Maurice Whatton MIEE, who just so happened to be one of the LS3/5A's designers. I checked it out, logged on to the accompanying website, and found the kind of enthusiasm which I wish permeated the entire home-ent community.

True, there were some saddos with anal-retentive qualities which would scare anyone new to audiophilia, but that comes with the territory: anoraks are both enthusiasts and psychotics, and the two characteristics are inseparable. You need it to fuel a news group. The topics ranged from what stands to use with the LS3/5As, to what's the best subwoofer, best amp, are JR149s as good, etc, etc, etc. Before I knew it, Paul and I had cooked up a plan to deal with the group's most oft-raised topic: what is the best LS3/5A of them all?

We realised that, without much difficulty, we could gather together examples of the most important ones, that I could easily find qualified listening panels, and that I had the perfect venue for auditioning a small monitor or 12. Over a period of some four months, I arranged three listening sessions with two listeners each, consistent right down to the room's ambient temperature. [68 degrees] The goal was to find which commercially-produced LS3/5A best approximated BBC-badged LS3/5A numbers 001/002, loaned to us by a private collector. Up against them were the following:

Audiomaster 15 ohm (loaned by web group member Deng Zhuo)
Chartwell kit version 15 ohm (assembled by and property of Paul Whatton)
Harbeth 11 ohm (loaned by Alan Shaw of Harbeth)
KEF 11 ohm (Kessler Kollection)
KEF 11 ohm lacquered (Kessler Kollection)
Rogers 11 ohm (Kessler Kollection)
Rogers 11 ohm lacquered (Kessler Kollection)
Rogers 11 ohm XLR (belonging to Andy Whittle of Exposure)
Rogers 15 ohm (property of Nic Poulsen of Trilogy)
Spendor 11 ohm (Kessler Kollection)
Spendor 15 ohm (from Spendor's Derek Hughes, once belonging to Spencer Hughes)

....
THE LISTENING SYSTEM

Because we wanted the system totally optimised for the LS3/5A, to be free of variation, to be consistent and to be easy to use, I settled on the Krell KPS25sc CD player as the best front-end, fed into the Musical Fidelity M3 integrated amplifier with Discovery cable. Naturally, there were calls for the speakers only to be driven by Quad IIs, or for the source to be vinyl, yadayadayada, but such naivety, indicative of people who have never undertaken a multi-unit test, was swiftly dismissed.
.....

LS3/5A TEST RESULTS

Now, what you've all been waiting for: the final tally. And, to my absolute delight, it proved to be thoroughly unpredictable, with only one of the news group's preconceptions - that the Chartwell was a killer - coming true:

1) Harbeth 11 ohm 257.5
2) Chartwell 15 ohm 243.5
3) Rogers 11 ohm (lacquered) 243
4) Spendor 15 ohm 239.5
5) Spendor 11 ohm 233.5
6) KEF 11 ohm (lacquered) 233
7) Rogers 15 ohm 230.5
8) KEF 11 ohm 226
9) Audiomaster 15 ohm 217
10) Rogers 11 ohm 212.5
11) Rogers 11 ohm XLR 197

覺得這測試有參考價值，不是結果評分，因評分的人有其個人取向，口味不一定跟自己相似，而是測試的認真態度及客觀性。

最後修改時間: 2018-06-11 12:27:27

spyder

正式會員
223.xxx.xxx.58

2018-06-11 12:23