影音天地主旨 ﹝請按主旨作出回應﹞  下頁  尾頁 寄件者 傳送日期 由舊至新 由新至舊
[#27] 係米用藍光ROM抓CD音軌靚聲的?    
如果部CD ROM 純粹讀取file(rip CD),基本上部部都可以做到。暫時又唔覺得有邊部cheap cheap地嘅CD ROM讀左個file出嚟但係實際開唔到。

如果你話燒碟,可能呢部機會好啲。


最後修改時間: 2020-03-07 15:57:08
DYreal
個人訊息 會員
119.xxx.xxx.115
2020-03-07 15:56
[#26] 係米用藍光ROM抓CD音軌靚聲的?    
現今有邊部家用電腦Rom寫和讀CD靚得過下面呢部
不妨介紹吓
http://www.plextor.com.tw/p-Premium2/index.htm


最後修改時間: 2020-03-07 15:55:32
kampo2
個人訊息 會員
61.xxx.xxx.206
2020-03-07 15:49
[#25] 係米用藍光ROM抓CD音軌靚聲的?    
What is the reason behind?
aheung
個人訊息 會員
219.xxx.xxx.129
2020-03-07 15:13
[#24] 係米用藍光ROM抓CD音軌靚聲的?    
Hi,

I installed dbpoweramp today at the 4th commputer and calibrated the setoff value with a AccurateRIP Key Disc.

I ripped a Linda Ronsdadt Simple Drames CD again today at the newly setup PC. the wave file got the same file size (exactly the same number of byte with the wave file I ripped 6 months ago.

The bluray-rom support C2 reporting function. The Audio CD got almost NO scratch.

Cheers!
Blau


blau.vol
個人訊息 會員
113.xxx.xxx.20
2011-10-16 22:02
[#23] 係米用藍光ROM抓CD音軌靚聲的?    
Hi Royal hing,

My experience sharing, I tried to rip the same NEWLY Bought Dave Brubeck Time Out CD in different computer(of course with different brands dvd-rom/blu ray drives.

All 3 computers using 3 different dvd-rom drives, 1 is Lite On , 1 is Pioneer, 1 is MacBook Pro.

All 3 rom drives set-off value is calibrated with AccurateRIP key disc. when I rip the same TimeOut disc in 3 different computers , THE wave files is identical. that is my experience with NEWLY boughht AudioCD.

For your info, all 3 dvd-rom drives got C2 reporting feature.

For a new bought AudioCD , as I said , normaly there is NO scratch, normally , they will read smoothly. NO C2 reporting kick in. You may set the dbPowerAmp or RIP software to try max 60 times or 100times, BUT if you have first 3 times data identical , you will never need to try 60 or 100times.

Have c2 reporting , that mean the dvd-rom drive believe the read data got some problem, and ask you to determine should I try or NOT to try again.

However, for dbPowerAmp, even that particular block does NOT report there is C2 error from dvd-rom drive, he still compare this block with previously read version to double check.

I remember there was 1 sharing by Kent Poon , he ripped 1 audio CD with different software in Mac, the wave files is NOT the same in size (as the dvdrom drive set off value is NOT input in the ripping software), however, when he align the set-off value in Audio Editing software, they ALL sound the same. How he know, he inverse 1 files polarity and play 2 files together. the OUTPUT GAIN is always 0dB (1 files setoff the others).

so, for a audioCD with NO scratch or nearly no scratch, there is C2 error reported. so, the audioCD will be the same.

for audioCD with scratch , C2 error will be reported, and there may be change Error Correction kick in and start to guess.
blau.vol
個人訊息 會員
113.xxx.xxx.57
2011-10-15 22:04
[#22] 係米用藍光ROM抓CD音軌靚聲的?    
Hi blau. vol,

Just a bit of sharing. In fact I have over 10 DVD/BD drives at home. Even with dBPoweramp's multiple comparsion enabled, it still sounds differently (in a small delta). The file size is also different.

My personal conclusion is retrying 100 times is still useless, given you're using the same drive with weaker C1/C2 EC. Remember a few yrs ago there was some popular "anti-pirate" technology released by Sony Music and Universal Music? They work by introducing extra C1/C2 noise into the disc to "fool" the computer use optical drives. Some drives manage to get through these "protections" as they have better C1/C2 handling algorithms that close to CDP.
Royal Horse
個人訊息 正式會員
222.xxx.xxx.63
2011-10-15 19:42
[#21] 係米用藍光ROM抓CD音軌靚聲的?    
hi Royal hing & cryingfreeman hing,

For dbPowerAmp or RIP in Mac, they can handle DVD-ROM with and Without C2 error reporting. and still can rip the audioCD in the most proper manner.

We can ask the dbPowerAMp to detect the DVD-ROM drive is it possible to detect c2 error, dbpoweramp will ask you to rip a CD which you use marker to cover part of the CD surface. then , their MUST BE c2 error, and the C2 error IS NOT RECORVERABLE . then dbPowerAmp will know your dvd-rom drive can report c2 error or not.

however, no matter it got c2 error reporting OR NOT. dbPowerAmp will still compare each captured bit for 2-3 times (you can set the least identical times in option menu)

I set try max. 100times for each bit for an CD and captured bits must be continuously 3 times IDENTICAL before it confirm that particular captured data is REAL and can be confirmed.

as it compared the bit in higher level Memory basis rather than using dvd-rom drive cache or C2 error reporting scheme, so either a rom got C2 reporting function will NOT affect the dbPoweramp result and function.

It read the captured data and compare in windows Memory area.

Actually, the RIP software in MasOS also using the same scheme in order to make sure the ripped data is correct , and other than compare 3 different samples. Both RIP and dbpoweramp also use AccurateRIP to report the data to the central database. To see is the RIPPED data (in track by track level) is identical to others' information when ripping the same AudioCD (same isdn #).

so, dbpoweramp can use or does not use rom drive's C2 reporting scheme and more important it uses memory to compare 3 or 4 times (value you can set in the option menu).

that is the scheme of dbpoweramp, the only times dbpoweramp GUESS the value of that particular bit (error correction kick off) is when he try read 100 times and STILL CANNOT certain what THAT bit should be (NO 3 times identical).

so, dbpoweramp is one of the best ripping software is because they don't care your rom drive quality and they compare it bit by bit in memory level.

hope my explanation is understandable and you can guess what I mean.

cheers!

blau

最後修改時間: 2011-10-14 17:19:49
blau.vol
個人訊息 會員
118.xxx.xxx.43
2011-10-14 17:14
[#20] 係米用藍光ROM抓CD音軌靚聲的?    
blau.vol and cryingfreeman hing,

May be as I said, old CD has more C1/C2 errors, which different drive FW and ripping software handle that differently.

As I know, Pioneer and Panasonic drives doesn't report C1/C2 error to host software. That means the EC is entirely handled by the drive itself rather than the ripping software.
Royal Horse
個人訊息 正式會員
218.xxx.xxx.229
2011-10-14 16:12
[#19] 係米用藍光ROM抓CD音軌靚聲的?    
blau

your info can save people time!
cryingfreeman
個人訊息 會員
220.xxx.xxx.118
2011-10-14 10:44
[#18] 係米用藍光ROM抓CD音軌靚聲的?    
hi cryingfree hing,

I am using dbPowerAmp & EAC for ripping, from my experience , after I setup properly for the dbPoweramp and EAC ,especially the dvd-rom or blu-ray rom offset using AccurateRIP required KEY DISC.

Then your rom is properly set. and when i rip the same AudioCD with a Lite-On DVD-Rom and with a Pioneer dvd-rom, the wav files are identical!

You can use the foobar2000 utility BitCompare to compare the solely the audio stream in bit level and you will know.

when I rip the same NEWLY BOUGHT Time Out audioCD with 2 different PCs, the wav files are identical when both rom are calibrated (offset value properly set).

When I rip a old CD (with scratch), the file size is NOT the same from dbPowerAmp and EAC and with different rom drive, it is because different software got different error correction algorithm, therefore the result is NOT the same.

cheers!
blau
blau.vol
個人訊息 會員
118.xxx.xxx.43
2011-10-14 10:12
[#17] 係米用藍光ROM抓CD音軌靚聲的?    
i have no servers in my home. i am still thinkijng the method for transmission.
any other sugguestion?
cryingfreeman
個人訊息 會員
220.xxx.xxx.118
2011-10-14 09:10
[#16] 係米用藍光ROM抓CD音軌靚聲的?    
cryingfreeman hing,

Pls check pm.
Royal Horse
個人訊息 正式會員
112.xxx.xxx.234
2011-10-13 20:18
[#15] 係米用藍光ROM抓CD音軌靚聲的?    
你就好啦, 我望住堆cd發愁, 估計有1500隻 ...
frappeccino
個人訊息 會員
27.xxx.xxx.142
2011-10-12 17:27
[#14] 係米用藍光ROM抓CD音軌靚聲的?    
royal horse hing
>>are the different files bit perfect from different drive?
Of course not, even the file size is changed.

is it meant that the file size is different with each other by different drive rom? If yes, a good lesson for me. just first time to hear! I use itune and eac to rip cd and both files are bit perfect. could you share your files ripped by different driver rom?

Actual sound quality also has noticeable difference, but not in a "Heaven vs Hell" degree.
yes, eac and itune sound quality also not same. i like eac than itune but itune can save me a lot of time in organising

Hence, I'll only recommend people to invest on a better optical drive given they have high end gears and experienced ears only.

well...i wont do that I have pioneer, liteon and lg which however, LG performance from forigner country testing that lg better performnace than pioneer. (talking about the acurancy in reading and writing) liteon is most poor

>>but by the way, could dbpower rip cd? i never use this
Both Linn and Yamaha recommend dBPowerAmp to rip CD for their network audio streamers.

ok...next time to use dbpoweramp to try in future (i finished my ripping to my cd bank ~600 nos cds)

最後修改時間: 2011-10-12 14:50:23
cryingfreeman
個人訊息 會員
220.xxx.xxx.118
2011-10-12 14:49
[#13] 係米用藍光ROM抓CD音軌靚聲的?    
Cryingfreeman:

>>are the different files bit perfect from different drive?
Of course not, even the file size is changed. Actual sound quality also has noticeable difference, but not in a "Heaven vs Hell" degree. Hence, I'll only recommend people to invest on a better optical drive given they have high end gears and experienced ears only.

>>but by the way, could dbpower rip cd? i never use this
Both Linn and Yamaha recommend dBPowerAmp to rip CD for their network audio streamers.

最後修改時間: 2011-10-12 14:20:30
Royal Horse
個人訊息 正式會員
218.xxx.xxx.229
2011-10-12 14:19
[#12] 係米用藍光ROM抓CD音軌靚聲的?    
I have several differnet drive. The file size even changed using the same dBPoweramp!
ha...
are the different files bit perfect from different drive?
you can then discuss seriously with mr. kent poon at cas section here!
but by the way, could dbpower rip cd? i never use this

最後修改時間: 2011-10-12 13:36:25
cryingfreeman
個人訊息 會員
220.xxx.xxx.118
2011-10-12 13:34
[#11] 係米用藍光ROM抓CD音軌靚聲的?    
其實用平價組合有無必要去考究jitter?
frappeccino
個人訊息 會員
27.xxx.xxx.142
2011-10-12 13:13
[#10] 係米用藍光ROM抓CD音軌靚聲的?    
>>>>will it be MORE 1 and 0 DATA?
will it be LESS JITTER?
will it be FILE SIZE REDUCED or Changed?
will it be DITIGIAL FILE TYPE CHANGED?

I have several differnet drive. The file size even changed using the same dBPoweramp! Back in Pentium III ages, the sound is different when direct playback Audio CD via different CD-ROM even with cheapie Sound Blaster Live and Windows Media Player.

Don't forget, different drive has different algorithm to correct C1/C2 errors. Also many technical review showing that Pioneer and Plextor drive with less jitters.

If u go through the Red Book CDDA spec, u'll understand why the 1 and 0 theory doesn't work at all in CDDA. The error tolerance and recovery correction of CDDA is much weaker than computer use CD-ROM. Even small invisible dust can affect the data integrity. Obviously it was a trade off for Sony/Philips engineers when they define the format back in late 1970s in order to gain for longer playback time per disc.

最後修改時間: 2011-10-12 13:08:26
Royal Horse
個人訊息 正式會員
218.xxx.xxx.229
2011-10-12 13:00
[#9] 係米用藍光ROM抓CD音軌靚聲的?    
del

最後修改時間: 2011-10-12 13:01:23
Royal Horse
個人訊息 正式會員
218.xxx.xxx.229
2011-10-12 12:56
[#8] 係米用藍光ROM抓CD音軌靚聲的?    
http://www.av-forums.net/plus/viewthread.php?tid=78127&extra=page%3D1&page=1

好感謝呢位坐言起行既師兄, 做咗咋們既明燈...
frappeccino
個人訊息 會員
27.xxx.xxx.142
2011-10-11 16:19
主旨內容一共有 2 頁,每頁顯示 20 個信息,選擇頁數:  下頁  尾頁
按照傳送日期顯示:由舊至新由舊至新  由新至舊由新至舊
最新資訊 - 影音
「AK4497EQ」解碼晶片+「響一」電容,SPEC 推出全新 Real Sound DA Converter 「RMP-DAC1」 2021-04-15

最新資訊 - 影音
Densen RCA 信號線 2021-04-15

最新資訊 - 影音
新色襲來,Yamaha SR-C20A 推出紅與白兩款全新色彩 2021-04-14

最新資訊 - 影音
Sony 發布 PS5 四月份大更新,將推出新的儲存空間選項及社交功能 2021-04-13