影音天地主旨 ﹝請按主旨作出回應﹞  下頁  尾頁 寄件者 傳送日期 由舊至新 由新至舊
[#18] 想請教一下 平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機分別    
I guess the better question is why wanna SACD player or buy SACD and have a listen to see if this is one's cup of tea. If I must listen to SACD, I probably would prefer a cheaper ones as the strength of SACD does not really suit my liking.

Just my own experience and preference of coz. I have listened to quite a few SACD recordings and somehow it always give me some kind of fake sound stage reproduction. The details is great I supposed but what really bothered me was the imagining being too pin point with clean edge between each point. Kind of reminds me of the earlier days LED TV when the things on the screen just looked like bits and pieces of paper cuts stick together. There is just less blending in of sounds like live music does. Quite distracting and definitely does not resembles true life music presentation if one wants to make their system sounds like real and lively.

最後修改時間: 2021-10-13 16:33:39
BenYC
個人訊息 正式會員
119.xxx.xxx.216
2021-10-13 16:24
[#19] 想請教一下 平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機分別    
如果冇極好聆聽空間,唔值得投資超高價器材。

>十分認同,冇咁嘅空間根本浪費咗啲靚器材
RCA073
個人訊息 正式會員
14.xxx.xxx.145
2021-10-13 16:57
[#20] 想請教一下 平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機分別    
#18,

May I know which SACD player and recording brought you such experience? So far, I am quite enjoy the SACD with good recording, no matter is on a Pioneer Universal Player or a million dollars SACD combo.......
blackspin
個人訊息 會員
218.xxx.xxx.149
2021-10-13 17:15
[#21] 想請教一下 平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機分別    
#20

A few marantz and dcs combo over the years but never paid attention to model numbers...

Yet, one should also note that I am no longer a keen "audiophile". I just want a system that sound normal and don't shout out "I'm here. I'm here.". I also stick to normal red book and youtube impresses me enough that I listen to YouTube 80% of the time these days.

最後修改時間: 2021-10-13 17:24:01
BenYC
個人訊息 正式會員
219.xxx.xxx.169
2021-10-13 17:23
[#22] 想請教一下 平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機分別    
#19.如果冇極好聆聽空間,唔值得投資超高價器材。


>>空間感比喻音响,就好似一輛行駛中汽車,

200ft 60km 300ft 80km , 1000ft 當然 130km 速度。

CS168
個人訊息 會員
1.xxx.xxx.217
2021-10-13 17:31
[#23] 想請教一下 平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機分別    
#20 我十多年前丶地庫賣的 大陸 XRCD(可能是假 SACD)丶真差丶但好sharp, 吉耳丶SACD 就未遇過

我的sacd 可能夠運丶沒有 #18 的問題丶多是多了"空氣感"丶鬆容

最後修改時間: 2021-10-13 17:53:42
phil.ng
個人訊息 會員
223.xxx.xxx.187
2021-10-13 17:50
[#24] 想請教一下 平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機分別    
#21

I see.......the Marantz and dCS should be relatively musical than some other SACD combo/player such as EMM Labs, CH Precision, Esoteric....... I think it is a kind of personal preference........ but lush, rich in details, high resolution but not being clinical is really demanding for most audiophile system.

I can understand what yo mean, my primary music source is Turntable, SACD/CD player is for easy listening or when I music that does not have vinyl. I think you will not compliant about the 3 dimensional imaging airy and spacious sound stage reproduced by Analog system, isn't it?
blackspin
個人訊息 會員
218.xxx.xxx.149
2021-10-13 18:00
[#25] 想請教一下 平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機分別    
#24

Indeed it all boils down to priority and preference.

I don't mind a lacking system but I cannot stand an overpowering one. In a way, missing certain details is fine for me but giving me extra will just drive me nuts. On top of that, many system can be tiring to ears after a short while. For me, if a system lacks resolution, all I need to do is to turn the volume down and it will resemble a far away listening perspective.

What many modern high res systems really bother me is that at normal listening level, the details just does not match the perceived distance. Say ,if I listening to a song with volume like the singer is 10 feet away, how can I also hear the singer's extreme solid focus and ultra breathing and saliva details which cannot be heard unless only inches away....

Again, I am no audiophile...
BenYC
個人訊息 正式會員
219.xxx.xxx.169
2021-10-13 18:24
[#26] 想請教一下 平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機分別    
平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機的最大分別是音質。我玩過兩三萬以下的 SACD 機,事後覺得畢如玩部好些的 CD 機。玩 SACD 機,要玩 top model, 或者至少要過十萬。

好的 SACD 機分析力好,除左假的 SACD, SACD 的音質比 CD 圓滑飽滿,低音沈實,高音順滑,整體聽來音色自然一啲,相對 SACD, CD 聲生硬少少,不過個要 AB 比較先聽得到,但同 LP 比都係差。

好的 CD 都已經好好聲,要唔要好的 SACD 機,睇個人追求啦。
Forfun
個人訊息 正式會員
84.xxx.xxx.170
2021-10-13 18:26
[#27] 想請教一下 平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機分別    
好多經典嘅錄音同埋演繹都冇出SACD

用嚟製作近代SACD嘅母帶已經殘破不堪

莫講話數碼器材,近代嘅再版黑膠碟都完全唔可以同頭版比較,聲音木訥欠鮮活

仲有好多近代製作嘅軟件都被多手仔搞到啲EQ不倫不類

仲有最緊要一樣野,好多頭版嘅CD 已經好靚聲,你俾我揀我寧願要頭版CD都好過要再版嘅SACD

Chord 嘅解碼經已證實咗red book format 都夠晒靚聲
Thanatos
個人訊息 正式會員
119.xxx.xxx.143
2021-10-13 18:37
[#28] 想請教一下 平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機分別    
試簡單答

去試同一廠丶如 Luxman 03 一路上到 10丶就會聴到一級級上的分別
phil.ng
個人訊息 會員
223.xxx.xxx.187
2021-10-13 23:29
[#29] 想請教一下 平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機分別    
#27: red book format 都夠晒靚聲X2
15--16
個人訊息 正式會員
223.xxx.xxx.95
2021-10-14 01:04
[#30] 想請教一下 平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機分別    
樓主問 平貴 Sacd player 分別, 就像有人問平貴 Porsche 分別丶由 Boxster 到 918 Spyde、911 GT2 RS

最正及快當然是918 Spyde。但答........香港路 Honda type R 就夠玩丶會不會是答不中丶離了題!?

就像廿多年前丶有人話丶DVD 倍線上 1080就夠睇丶現時就知吾夠!

其實 DSD format 全嬴 pcm 16/44.1, 如用同一"母帶", 同一製作人丶同一mixing panel, 同一部 CD/SACD player, DSD/SACD一定靚過 16/44.1

最後修改時間: 2021-10-14 11:53:16
phil.ng
個人訊息 會員
223.xxx.xxx.187
2021-10-14 11:47
[#31] 想請教一下 平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機分別    
#27.
呢樣真!
話說有班新手連反相都聽唔出!
CodyChan
個人訊息 會員
113.xxx.xxx.137
2021-10-14 11:47
[#32] 想請教一下 平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機分別    
幾十年前嘅經典錄音就買頭版CD算了

近代錄音(唔係remastered,真係最近先至錄製) 就可以買SACD 玩吓
Thanatos
個人訊息 正式會員
119.xxx.xxx.143
2021-10-14 12:00
[#33] 想請教一下 平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機分別    
#30

SACD、DSD 制式的確係好好

但係軟件未必配合到,經典錄音remastered 成為SACD,失去咗好多嘢

所以我哋嘅Focus應否集中響貴價SACD 或DSD 重播儀器身上?

如果Milstein 錄製佢嗰啲Bach Sonatas Partitas 嘅時候有得選擇DSD 或者red book, 我毫無疑問會揀DSD

至於用價錢來衡量品質,我個人認為只適合用於同一隻牌子嘅產品圍內作比較。 你俾無限咁多錢我發板,我會揀Chord 唔揀dCS (Chord 平一大截)
Thanatos
個人訊息 正式會員
119.xxx.xxx.143
2021-10-14 12:09
[#34] 想請教一下 平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機分別    
#31

大部分古典cd都係反相,唔好話新手,老手都係當正相咁聽
RCA073
個人訊息 正式會員
14.xxx.xxx.174
2021-10-14 12:30
[#35] 想請教一下 平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機分別    
有關正相反相嘅問題

我曾經問過雲吞河:當鼓手一野打落個鼓嘅時候,喇叭震膜應該係彈出嚟定彈入去?

佢話佢都唔知亦都冇諗過

不過唔少發燒友家中、展覽場地、show room 都試過一邊喇叭相位(正負) 駁錯,在場幾十人冇一個聽得出,呢樣先係最離譜
Thanatos
個人訊息 正式會員
119.xxx.xxx.143
2021-10-14 12:35
[#36] 想請教一下 平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機分別    
其實響音樂製作過程中,有啲樂器係需要刻意做反相特顯佢嘅存在,所以最終你話呢個係正相定反相錄音,我諗連錄音師自己都說不定。

DYreal
個人訊息 正式會員
14.xxx.xxx.232
2021-10-14 12:44
[#37] 想請教一下 平價sacd機 同貴價sacd機分別    
相信以前啲100%音樂,電影等等都己經全部數碼化了。就算如來神掌都可以係YouTube睇到。曾經係20年前聽Sony 一個presentation 講點樣修復舊電影:係不惜功本,make sure 100年之後,e啲電影仲係生金蛋嘅雞,不停搵錢。BTW 我哋買到嘅,只係down size format,因為勁數碼架生仲未普及化係街度買到。

當然就算YouTube,都會有好多人upload 480p source into 1080p format,咁樣話1080p 唔掂冇得講。

Anyway 如果仲有人聽過Sony 20年前岀SACD時,出個批SACD to demo SACD superiority,人哋SACD比CD多4倍bit 數,咁都唔好聲,又冇得好講。

今時今日,個個手機同streaming services 都compress music movie content bit 數,減低成本,OK fine。音樂未必人人聽得岀分別,但係話Netflix 4K is as good as 4K blu ray which has at least 多4倍bit 數,可以省略一大筆錢買靚靚電視了。




最後修改時間: 2021-10-14 12:52:27
Kenny
個人訊息 正式會員
14.xxx.xxx.22
2021-10-14 12:49
主旨內容一共有 5 頁,每頁顯示 20 個信息,選擇頁數:  下頁  尾頁
按照傳送日期顯示:由舊至新由舊至新  由新至舊由新至舊
最新資訊 - 影音
即將亮相慕尼黑,Esoteric 發布正式版本 Grandioso T1 黑膠唱盤 2022-05-19

最新資訊 - 影音
【夏季日本祭】AIM 全線產品 8 折優惠 2022-05-18

最新資訊 - 影音
Sony 發表全新一代藍牙降噪耳機 WH-1000XM5 2022-05-17

最新資訊 - 影音
平板聲勢 破鏡而出 CAMPFIRE AUDIO SUPERMOON 2022-05-17