| 影音軟件主旨 ﹝請按主旨作出回應﹞ | 寄件者 | 傳送日期
|
| [#1] 呂珊 : 金嗓子 我很喜歡聽呂珊的歌，但並非像各位大佬咁幸福有部靚hi fi。 所以我只是可以從普通用家的角度來評論呢隻碟。正好似上一隻星光背後一樣，金嗓子又一次令我失望。當然，環星的碟並不可以用發燒碟的角度來評論。 但金嗓子無論在編曲，演繹，變化或呂珊的唱奶W，明顯無花過奶牷C 有幾首歌仲好似唔夠氣唱。 成隻碟坁犖t繹好平版，好似全部一式一樣。 唔知係唔係妏鵀菑v唱極都無氣息有關。 反觀羅敏莊就愈唱愈好。 編曲都無新意，比起老歌集乏味得多。 我知道環星是針對年紀大，平民化的，喜歡聽金曲的人的路線。 但起碼要做碟要d誠意唔好粗製濫造，令本來好聽的，也變成唔好讓俾左錢又喜歡金曲的人浪費金錢。 希望庋演唱會成扔o揮一貫的表現就好了。 |
ketone 正式會員144.xxx.xxx.90 |
2006-03-13 18:04 | |
|
|
|||
| [#2] 呂珊 : 金嗓子 我覺得ketone太大反應，我也買了這張新CD，感覺上呂珊唱法是累積多年演唱經驗加上懷舊情懷並配合原有的編曲模式而演繹的。喜歡呂珊聲音的歌迷一定會接受。是此碟之編曲是儘量忠於原著而聽落有一份濃厚的懷舊味道。感覺好正！並非其他新編新唱的不倫不類。舊歌就是舊歌，何須整色整水，自然不造作好比新瓶舊酒或舊酒新瓶好。而全碟選曲很好，好有代表性，是見証國語歌曲蘆鬫~代的歷程。 |
大少 正式會員 203.xxx.xxx.97 |
2006-03-14 19:29 |
| [#3] 呂珊 : 金嗓子 ...I like Rosanna's voice, especially like her English singing disc ---"Yesterday". Frankly I have had her previous disc(s) before and prepare to buy this one also. |
ikent 正式會員 61.xxx.xxx.147 |
2006-03-15 13:35 |
| [#4] 呂珊 : 金嗓子 各位兄弟， 隻碟的聲不錯，人聲厚．中音靚． |
Yuhin 正式會員 219.xxx.xxx.110 |
2006-03-15 23:08 |
| [#5] 呂珊 : 金嗓子 Agreed! I've bought this new CD and feel very happy and satisfaction to the quality especially when you listen alone, you can recall a lot of sweet memories on those good old days. Music with great voice can make you feel alive no matter it's a audiophile recording or not. Am I rught? I totally like this album although I'm not old. I don't like what Ketone has criticised "Rosanne"& "WSM"'s efforts to this album with his unfair angle. Anyone who has seen Rosanne's concert on 9/3 & 10/3? Please give comments. |
Ahlam 正式會員 218.xxx.xxx.183 |
2006-03-16 02:29 |
| [#6] 呂珊 : 金嗓子 I was there on 9/3 concert. Her live performance was absolutely stunning. The concert was split into several completely different sessions with distinctive style. Rosanne was, IMO, the most versatile female singer in HK. Anyone who was in the concert would have agreed. This was the best concert I had attended. For those Rosanne fans who missed the show, you really missed the biggest diamond! "Yesterday" was the album and very good recording. Much much better than those chicken sounded HK younger singers and China singers like Chan Kit Lei. My rating is for the concert. THis album I have not yet bought but will buy |
123 正式會員 202.xxx.xxx.21 |
2006-03-16 12:33 |
| [#7] 呂珊 : 金嗓子 十分同意123所形容「呂珊閃閃星光夜」演唱會的精彩演出。我是看10/3晚的，當晚呂珊之演繹簡直是用文字難以形容。歌曲安排別具心思，歌曲種類包羅萬有，由經典國、粵語情歌，小調及平喉小曲、英文情歌跳舞歌一一揮洒自如，歌聲清澈嚮亮，高中低音兼容，澎湃中可低婉，抒情中有power，錯過了肯定是損失。現今樂壇珊姐唱旦磥O超凡，絕對是No.1。如有其他老友也看過，請交流竟見。另外，新CD金嗓子已聽過，感覺也很正。選曲好、編曲有懷舊情feel、唱奶@流、錄音也不錯，是喜歡舊曲重新的最佳選擇。 |
Lamjai 正式會員 203.xxx.xxx.97 |
2006-03-16 19:40 |
| [#8] 呂珊 : 金嗓子 我也有去3月9日的演唱會。那晚呂珊病了還唱得好才利害。她的呼吸聲很明顯(由其是後半場)﹐但高音準低音清﹐無一點感冒的鼻音。選歌方面﹐除了粵曲和黃梅調之 外﹐其他的歌四十歲以上的中坑如我全部也可跟@唱﹐除了[無賴]。呂珊選了[無賴]同聽眾大合唱有點失策﹐因為好像識唱的不多﹐如果是[老鼠愛大米]應該好好多。 很喜歡呂珊唱[I WILL ALWAYS LOVE YOU]﹐從不喜歡WHITNEY HOUSTON的版本﹐太剛。呂珊唱到[I WILL ALWAYS LOVE YOU]應該是演唱會的高潮﹐因為其他的歌都比較抒情﹐掌聲多但現場熱不起來﹐可惜以是尾聲。另外﹐中段有鋼琴加獨唱(本來還有兩個結他加獨唱和嘉賓蘇珊的表演都在第二晚刪掉)。 |
bladephilia 正式會員 203.xxx.xxx.33 |
2006-03-16 22:26 |
| [#9] 呂珊 : 金嗓子 各位網友，對於Ketone在首次推介呂珊新CD金嗓子時不公平及有針對性的言論我甚為不滿。還將香港唱得最好的靚聲后呂珊來跟歌藝一般平凡的羅敏莊來比較，實在令人氣結及懷疑Ketone這種行徑是否另有所圖。相信很多綱友曾經係TVB節目「超級靚聲演鬥廳」看過呂珊同羅敏莊的同台演出及歌藝比較已知答案。（我也不用多批評羅的歌唱技巧及氣量不足等等表現）希望Ketone日後在評論歌者發表自己意見時不要與某一歌手來比較，亦希望以較中肯的言論及對在樂壇默默耕耘的歌者公平的對待及表示的欣賞。不知其他網友意見如何? |
Kwokchai 正式會員 203.xxx.xxx.97 |
2006-03-17 15:06 |
| [#10] 呂珊 : 金嗓子 The facts has spoken for itself. Mimi Lo is more skillful than Rosanne Lui? Thank you very much for the amusement! |
123 正式會員 203.xxx.xxx.33 |
2006-03-21 00:03 |
| [#11] 呂珊 : 金嗓子 Everyone except a fool should know the truth behind this amusement! |
Ahlam 正式會員 218.xxx.xxx.49 |
2006-03-21 01:58 |
| [#12] 呂珊 : 金嗓子 呂珊唱打N如法拉利，羅敏莊就如三輪車，用兩者比較直頭係浪費時間。 |
goldenboy8969 正式會員 219.xxx.xxx.228 |
2006-03-21 10:44 |
| [#13] 呂珊 : 金嗓子 ＞＞＞＞....用兩者比較直頭係浪費時間。 Totally agreed!! |
ikent 正式會員 61.xxx.xxx.204 |
2006-03-21 13:52 |
| [#14] 呂珊 : 金嗓子 根本無得比! Shame on Ketone!! |
大少 正式會員 218.xxx.xxx.64 |
2006-03-22 02:31 |
| [#15] 呂珊 : 金嗓子 買了此碟一聽,發覺此碟質素一般,尤其錄音&編曲更寧人失望.環星可唔可以做好d呀! side晒呂珊把聲!!!! |
ricky88aa 正式會員 219.xxx.xxx.73 |
2006-03-22 14:43 |
| [#16] 呂珊 : 金嗓子 講唱 當然係薑愈老愈辣 我有兩隻呂珊既CD. 係 ROCK IN MUSIC 錄音的. 兩隻CD都OK. 唔知金嗓子的錄音是否OK. 可唔可以用來做試音CD. |
PLL 正式會員 203.xxx.xxx.165 |
2006-03-29 22:14 |
| [#17] 呂珊 : 金嗓子 I was in her 1st 's concert, her performance is absolutely fabalous, really can't believe HK has a singer can sing so well and able to perform so many different style of music! Love her! For her 金嗓子 cd... um... I don't think it's as good as her other previous CDs, may be as other brothers said it's just good coz it keeps those old song's original style, for me, I rather like a new arrangement. The recording seems not very good but acceptable. Her English CD from Rock music is a must buy. Nice sound and performance! |
keith 正式會員 124.xxx.xxx.105 |
2006-03-31 20:45 |
| [#18] 呂珊 : 金嗓子 這隻碟的聲音令人非常失望，我受上面的評論誤導，買了該碟，聽了兩首歌就要換碟，可以說，這隻碟簡直浪費了呂珊的唱央A唱片公司完全沒有為樂迷誠意製作。 |
kinhungw 正式會員 218.xxx.xxx.97 |
2006-05-01 11:00 |
| 按照傳送日期顯示:由舊至新 由新至舊
|
