影音軟件主旨 ﹝請按主旨作出回應﹞  下頁  尾頁 寄件者 傳送日期 由舊至新 由新至舊
[#1] 蔡琴 CD Suggestion    
Hi All,

I already have 金片子第一集 (SACD) & found it is really good CD for both songs & receording. So for now, I will consider to buy one more 蔡琴 CD. Please give suggestion that should I buy 金片子第二集之魂縈舊夢 or 民歌蔡琴?? Please also advise the CD version such as XRCD2 or SACD?? Thanks.

One more quetion: Must XRCD2 be made in Japan only??
freesongbird
個人訊息 會員
167.xxx.xxx.32
2004-11-02 13:59
[#2] 蔡琴 CD Suggestion    
"機遇" 必買 !!
check it review here.
pk
個人訊息 會員
221.xxx.xxx.144
2004-11-02 22:09
[#3] 蔡琴 CD Suggestion    
If just have these 2 CD for selection, what will be your choice??

1/ 金片子第二集之魂縈舊夢 (SACD or XRCD2) or
2/ 民歌蔡琴 (SACD or XRCD2)
freesongbird
個人訊息 會員
167.xxx.xxx.32
2004-11-03 17:17
[#4] 蔡琴 CD Suggestion    
I bought both 民歌蔡琴 and 機遇 last week (XRCD2 version). 機遇 is not my cup is tea. 民歌蔡琴 on the other hand is a must buy. The song 恰似你的溫柔 is so touching. My comment is that it's even better than the 無間道 song 被遺忘的時光.

I also would like to hear comment on 金片子第二集.
deka
個人訊息 會員
202.xxx.xxx.228
2004-11-03 17:48
[#5] 蔡琴 CD Suggestion    
I am also interested in 民歌蔡琴, but I am afraid it may be boring.
Which songs would you recommend except these 2 popular one?? Overall, how many songs worth to listen lei??
freesongbird
個人訊息 會員
167.xxx.xxx.33
2004-11-03 19:15
[#6] 蔡琴 CD Suggestion    
其實三隻都要買, 初聽就民歌好 D, 聽耐o左 金片子都好正, 隻機遇更加無得講...比人一種安寧感覺, 聽落好有味道
peterso
個人訊息 會員
210.xxx.xxx.58
2004-11-03 23:17
[#7] 蔡琴 CD Suggestion    
Actually, the said CDs of Ms Choi are real excellent ...
Its recording from xrcd is top top excellent ...I got most of her xrcd collections.

I feel that the recording of 金片子 1/2 are the best ... very natural and dynamic. Of course I mean a bit better, not too far. The songs of 民歌, 機遇, 金片子 are all very good.

If you are her fan, you should get all of them ...
ptopto
個人訊息 會員
218.xxx.xxx.243
2004-11-04 21:37
[#8] 蔡琴 CD Suggestion    
Hi Ptopto,

you have 金片子1 & 2 xrcd, but many reviews stated SACD is better than xrcd of these 2 albums. Is it true?? my version is SACD.

so if I buy 金片子 2 & 民歌, which version should I buy?? SACD or xrcd??
freesongbird
個人訊息 會員
218.xxx.xxx.92
2004-11-04 23:40
[#9] 蔡琴 CD Suggestion    
金片子 1&2, 我 sacd 同 xrcd 都有, 本來係祗係有 sacd, 但o向我個 friend 度比較過 sacd / xrcd 版本, 立即走去買返 xrcd, xrcd 版本 無論 dynamic, 力度, details 同空氣感都好過 sacd
peterso
個人訊息 會員
210.xxx.xxx.49
2004-11-05 01:17
[#10] 蔡琴 CD Suggestion    
Are your xrcd made in Japan?? Did it print at back side of cover?? where did you buy?? I found the cheapest one at $205. Pls advise if you find much cheaper.
freesongbird
個人訊息 會員
167.xxx.xxx.33
2004-11-05 14:58
[#11] 蔡琴 CD Suggestion    
I am delighted to learn that the xrcd of Ms Choi are of excellent quality.

In my system, these 2 xrcds revealed as best as some other best sacd I had. So the format of xrcd/sacd does not matter, what matters is the quality of recording and process of production.

I have some experience that I bought few sacds and end up selling them in few days time.

yes, most of txrcds are made in Japan. It is usually printed at the back of the cover ... you can see it.

cheers.
ptopto
個人訊息 會員
210.xxx.xxx.172
2004-11-05 16:35
[#12] 蔡琴 CD Suggestion    
If no "made in Japan" marked on back side of xrcd or just printed "manufactured by JVC Japan", that means it is not made in Japan ??

Ptopto, would you mind telling us about your audio equipment??

freesongbird
個人訊息 會員
167.xxx.xxx.32
2004-11-05 18:15
[#13] 蔡琴 CD Suggestion    
freesongbird,
-my 民歌xrcd is not marked "made in japan" at the back cover ... still I feel it is a very good cd.

-i'm not too much bothered by these labels ... of course I presume the EMI 百代 does not issue different versions.

- I understand that for 金片子1 & 2 xrcd, they might have 2 different versions (differs by the packing : one version is having noraml transparent cd-holder; another version is having paper type slot-in holder). I know this because my friend bought the paper type slot-in holder version and show me ...). We did not compare the sounding ...

Anyway, you are very cautious as you have asked many questions before deciding to buy which & what ...? Have you made up yr mind ...

For cd, I used Wadia 25 for cd before and now using Marantz 14v2, also using Mark amp ...plus many US branded gears / cables.
ptopto
個人訊息 會員
218.xxx.xxx.110
2004-11-05 20:49
[#14] 蔡琴 CD Suggestion    
freesongbird,
I saw today in Wanchai - 集成 cd shop, 金片子 xrcd is around 150-, pls try there. Thry have other Ms Choi's xrcd too ...

go luck.
ptopto
個人訊息 會員
218.xxx.xxx.110
2004-11-05 20:54
[#15] 蔡琴 CD Suggestion    
Hi ptopto,

Yes, I bought 金片子2 xrcd2, transparent plastic cd holder & marked "made in Japan" at back cover. This is my 1st xrcd. I did not listen yet. Will keep posted the feedback after listening.

May be I asked too much. I apologize if make you uncomfortable...
freesongbird
個人訊息 會員
219.xxx.xxx.161
2004-11-06 01:31
[#16] 蔡琴 CD Suggestion    
綠版機偶一定要買,超超正
宗仔
個人訊息 會員
221.xxx.xxx.45
2004-11-06 16:25
[#17] 蔡琴 CD Suggestion    
我隻係普通綠版,碟內圈有新版字樣果
宗仔
個人訊息 會員
221.xxx.xxx.45
2004-11-06 16:30
[#18] 蔡琴 CD Suggestion    
freesongbird,
Congratulation ... you have got one of the very best xrcds. Hope you'll enjoy it ...

It's ok to ask questions ... as I'm like you when start to buy more fancy cds / gears ... you have to ask in order to become a smarter consumer. I have much pleasure to share things I knew.

Cheers & happy listening.


ptopto
個人訊息 會員
218.xxx.xxx.67
2004-11-06 19:01
[#19] 蔡琴 CD Suggestion    
Hi Ptopto,

Thanks for your recommendation.

oh... xrcd is really better than SACD for voice performance that her voice is definitely true & realistic. Moreover, you may listen more details which SACD cannot. However, all things are outstanding, in other words, it may be little noisy. On the other hand, for SACD, the background is relatively silent & all things are soft, so you have to adjust the volume little higher. Actually, both versions also have thier own characteristics/advantage.

Regarding to the songs between vol.1 & 2, both are very good. You cannot miss one of another. Personally, I like vol.2 more.
freesongbird
個人訊息 會員
219.xxx.xxx.231
2004-11-07 14:11
[#20] 蔡琴 CD Suggestion    
金片子SACD及XRCD版我都有,我較為喜歡SACD版,SACD版分晰細緻、人聲溫暖、中高音甜潤,我覺得XRCD版混音時電平偏高,太數碼化,聽落好似係好聲D,但其實只不過將這張碟的原有錄音訊號處理後,放大及加:而以,反而破壞了享受此碟的真正樂趣,聽琴姐唱歌除了錄音好之外,最重要是能細味出人聲中所帶出的味道:醇、厚、清、甜,我本人推薦SACD版。

其他推介:民歌蔡琴(最早期台灣版)、機遇(綠色版),這兩張CD我只有這兩個版,我沒聽過或比較過其他版本,不置意見。
nat
個人訊息 會員
219.xxx.xxx.42
2004-11-09 11:49
主旨內容一共有 2 頁,每頁顯示 20 個信息,選擇頁數:  下頁  尾頁
按照傳送日期顯示:由舊至新由舊至新  由新至舊由新至舊
最新資訊 - 影音
1MORE ANC TWS 價格調整與眾同樂 2020-10-24

最新資訊 - 汽車
Tesla 推出 「Drive to Believe」 七天試駕體驗 2020-10-23

最新資訊 - 影音
Epson 推出全新 FULL HD 投影機 EH-TW5750 / EH-TW5750S 2020-10-22

最新資訊 - 數碼
LG 推出革命性 PuriCare™ 穿戴式空氣清新機 2020-10-22